The Power of 3 – Three Song Harmonically Mixed Indoor Cycling Set – “Stairway to Heaven”

The Power of 3 – Three Song Harmonically Mixed Indoor Cycling Set – “Stairway to Heaven”

Stairway

 

The Power of 3 – “Stairway To Heaven”

“Rhiannon” by Stevie Nicks

“Come On Eileen” by Dexie’s Midnight Runners

“Stairway To Heaven” by Heart

For years I had been patiently waiting for the facilities I instruct in to upgrade their bikes to use power.  When these upgrades finally started to happen I was surprised by the different wattage readings I would see, not only, from different brands of bikes but by bikes built by the same manufacturer.   I had always assumed a watt is a watt the same way a MPH is MPH or an RPM is an RPM.  At first this was VERY disappointing, I have a very technical teaching style and I was hoping to have all my class participants perform a Functional Threshold Power (FTP) Test every 6-8 weeks, calculate their personal power zones and coach each and every class to those zones.  Unfortunately, if every bike in the studio reads wattage, even a little bit, differently I would need to adjust my teaching style.

[wlm_private ‘PRO-Platinum|PRO-Monthly|PRO-Gratis|PRO-Seasonal|Platinum-trial|Monthly-trial|PRO-Military|30-Days-of-PRO|90 Day PRO|Stages-Instructor|Schwinn-Instructor|Instructor-Bonus|28 Day Challenge’]

I needed to figure out a way to use this new technology, even with it’s faults, effectively to give my participants the best workout possible. I decided that the FTP test was still going to be an integral part of my programming and I would still perform this test every 6-8 weeks.  I asked my class participants to find 2-3 bikes that they believe are similar in wattage readings and ride those bikes as often as possible.  Small differences are ok, large ones make zone training impossible.  I also needed a technique to “dial in” new riders, those who never performed the FTP and others who may be forced to ride an unfamiliar bike.  I decided to start every class with a proper warm followed by a mini threshold test that I call a “Threshold Check”.  This “Threshold Check” can last anywhere between 4-6 minutes and I ask class participants to ride at their maximum sustainable intensity or wattage for the duration of this short test.  If the bikes are equipped with a console that will show average wattage I ask for the class to find their average wattage for this “Check”.  If the bikes do not have a way of reading average wattage I ask the class to be aware of their wattage throughout the “Check” and choose a wattage that they believe is closest to their maximum sustainable wattage.  If I’m teaching on a bike that is not equipped with a power meter I still perform this “threshold check” and i do my best to “anchor” effort with threshold RPE.  I also like to “anchor” effort and RPE during the FTP .  Most FTP tests last 20 minutes, so 10 minutes into a FTP effort I’ll explain that the feelings participants are experiencing, slight breathlessness. burning sensation in the legs and the need to stay extremely focused or wattage will drop is how a threshold effort “feels” and I ask them to associate  this feeling with whatever RPE number is used as threshold in the facility I’m teaching in.

Now that each participant has a threshold wattage or RPE to work with I break my profiles down into 3 zones: Above Threshold, Around Threshold and Below Threshold.  Efforts that are Above Threshold (greater than 106% of threshold) can last up to 8 minutes, efforts around threshold (90-105% of threshold) can last up to 30 minutes and below threshold efforts (less than 90% of threshold) can last up to 3 hours.

Check out the recorded classes below to hear how I use this “Threshold Check” in a class setting.

A detailed set profile to print

The_Power_of_3_Rhiannon_Come_On_Eileen_Stairway

 

3 song harmonically mixed track, to download Right Click > Save As / Save Target As to download. Open in iTunes and then you’ll see this in your Spotify Local File folder.

 

Recording of me teaching this 3 song set in a class on a Spinner Blade Ion, Right Click > Save As / Save Target As to download on PC or Download Linked File As on Mac. Open in iTunes and then you’ll see this in your Spotify Local File folder.

 

Recording of me teaching this 3 song set in a class on a Spinner NXT , Right Click > Save As / Save Target As to download on PC or Download Linked File As on Mac. Open in iTunes and then you’ll see this in your Spotify Local File folder.

 

3 song harmonically mixed song AND video,  to download Right Click > Save As / Save Target As to download.

Did this help?

[/wlm_private]

 

 

 

Indoor Cycling Power Research #7: Good News, Bad News

Indoor Cycling Power Research #7: Good News, Bad News

Different Methods Same Skewed Results

Confusing Data

A different approach with a professional researcher still produced mixed results

Let’s start with the good news. I’m sorry, I was completely pulling your leg. I really don’t have any good news. I know, that’s terrible — you can throw pencils and small farm animals at me next time you see me. I was really looking for the good news in these results and I just can’t find any. This last series of retesting the same three bikes to see if we could garner the same or similar results each time we measure the bike has led to 2 out of the 3 bikes demonstrating a “skewed distribution” of data. In other words, data that you could not and should not try to predict with because they are in a word, unreliable. That means my hope for creating a “handicap” for each bike to render them even and fair for comparisons and competitions is not possible.

Statistical measurements often use Standard Deviation to determine how much variation there is in the individual readings or occurrences of data (in our cases — the differences between the actual power and the measured power). There is something called the “Emperical Rule” (http://www.pmean.com/08/SdTooBig.html) “…it says that approximately 95% of the data lies between plus and minus two standard deviations of the mean.” This 95% rule is for data with a “normal distribution”.   This is what we were hoping for when we measured the same bike several times.

Please remember, this stage of the research was RE-measuring the same bikes, not measuring the differences in power between bike computer and actual power of the power pedals. We knew all along the pure accuracy would not be there, we were simply hoping that the amount or degree to which it was “off” would be consistent.

So getting back to our “Empirical Rule”. There is a corollary to that principle, and that is “If a non-negative set of data (which we have with our power numbers study) has a standard deviation that is more than half of the mean, it is an indication that the data deviates substantially from a bell shaped curve. Almost always this is an indication of a skewed distribution.” The second column to the end (right side) indicates if the distribution of repeat, same bike readings has a skewed distribution or not.

Bike Power retests

Bike 14 tested 3 separate times, looking for consistency between tests, for reliability to set bike handicaps.

With bike #14, it is notable that Trial #2 and #3 area actually fairly close except for at the 175 Watt stage. However, when we add our first set of numbers to the analysis, all but two wattage levels are skewed. If we just consider 1 bike, we might make a case that if we were to do 5 to 10 repeat trials, we might see these better numbers continue. This was something Sarah (our statistician) suggested as a next possible phase of the research; to conduct a much higher number of trials to see if we begin to see greater consistency or normalcy to the data.

power test results

Bike 1 tested 3 separate times, looking for consistency between tests, for reliability to set bike handicaps.

Again, with bike #1 we have only 2 out of 7 different wattage stages that are not demonstrating a skewed distribution of data. At a “gut feel” level, I was hoping to see less than 5 watts difference between measurements of power when it was the same stage. I was willing to accept a difference of 10 watts since accuracy was still not the main driver here. However, again we must remember this is not the power difference, but just the repeating values on the same bike — how reliable it is for a consistent representation of power. Unfortunately, 30% of all the individual stages rendered differences greater than 10 watts and statistically 4 out of the 7 stages were considered skewed.

A Glimmer of Hope?

power results

Bike 19 tested 3 separate times, looking for consistency between tests, for reliability to set bike handicaps.

Our last bike does seem to show a glimmer of hope though. While this specific bike had some of the largest differences in actual to measure power differences (in the 15 to 25 watt range), at least it showed those big swings fairly consistently. Notice how small the Standard Deviation is compared to the average delta (simply means the difference) among all three trials. This thus demonstrates a more “normal” distribution and could indeed support a type of “Power Handicap”.

So perhaps I have saved the good news for last. Maybe… just maybe, this means that some bikes would be amenable to a type of handicap while others may not. Picking up on Sarah’s suggestion, a lot more research (translate that — time spent repeating tests on the same bikes, many bikes) might lead to a set of bikes that are “good to go” with a handicap, and a set that are not. Naturally, being the proverbial curious cat, I would want to find out if there is some reason the unreliable bikes are that way. We might even be able to take those bikes through a preventive maintenance routine, recalibrate them to the furthest extent, and repeat the same retests. If we come up with a majority of the bikes being statistically solid and reliable, then we have not only created a handicap system, but we’ve validated the calibration method.

However, having spent as many hours as I have so far on this project, I’ve hung my lab coat up for now, so you won’t be blinded by science from me or a while. If I were Keiser corporation though, I believe I would have a vested interest in picking up where this research left off. I have moved this conundrum past the “blank page” and created a possible path that they could very well negotiate to a workable solution for their clients. Perhaps many clients don’t care. I get that – not everyone even uses the training tools. Yet they were bold enough to lead the industry with power and have played a major role in seeing this industry change for the good. I believe Joe Public is becoming increasingly more savvy when it comes to training, and this is rapidly becoming a more educated marketplace. Especially if they consider just their own clients, such an undertaking should be received very well, supporting their image as a company that takes training seriously enough to put in the time and energy to make it right.

Indoor Cycling Power Research #5: Show Me The Numbers!

Indoor Cycling Power Research #5: Show Me The Numbers!

 

Show me the numbers

It’s time to look at the data gathered so far.

Time To Dig In
So we’ve painstakingly done everything possible to setup and prepare our methods for a solid research project — at least as solid as any “non-university” research setting can hope for. We’ve not only established a consistent protocol for conducting the tests, but we’ve also made sure to not do too many in any one day, nor to use different testers to eliminate potential influences to our results.

Once we executed these tests on about a dozen bikes, I wanted to start to analyze the data, and that’s when it occurred to me that we needed to make sure that the numbers I was about to analyze were reliable and repeatable from bike to bike. My last post demonstrated the process of re-testing to insure that very thing. After doing retests on about 6 of the 12 bikes, it is now finally time to review the data and see just what is what.

Let’s Start With The First 2 Bikes
Each day I tested only 2 bikes — to make sure I was fresh each time. So naturally, my first peak at the numbers (and I try not to look at them until I am well into the research so that initial impressions do not subconsciously alter my performance as more tests are conducted) came after these first 2 retests. Remember, I’m into the research project a couple of months now without letting myself “have a taste” — that’s pretty tough for a data-geek like me ☺.  So below you will see the first two bikes retested. Let’s go over the columns so we can understand what we are looking at.

Keiser m3

1st Keiser m3 Indoor Cycling bike with power to be tested & retested.

Indoor Cycle Bike power data

2nd Keiser m3 Indoor Cycling Power bike tested with the Garmin Vector Pedals

The first column represents the 25 Watt stages that were used to get the average power numbers from. These were “settled into” for 2 to 3 minutes at each of these stages. More specifically I used the Keiser console to establish a steady wattage level during each stage, and then once the 2.5 minutes were up, I stopped the keiser to get the true average (which typically was within 5 watts of the target) and we also lapped the Garmin so it would later give us the average or “Normalized Power” (NPower is how I have referred to it on the table) from the Garmin Vector Power Pedals.

Column: Keiser Power Div by Garmin NPower
By dividing the calculated power of the bike by the measured power from the Vector power pedals, we will see by percentage just how close they are to each other. Remember, we are not concerned about pure accuracy per se — we know the calculated power is going to be inaccurate by its nature — we simply want to know how much it is off, and if that amount is reliable every time re ride that bike. Each percentage is a reflection of both bikes at a specific wattage on one test.

Column: Degree of Variation
If we now take the difference between the first test and the next, we can get at how reliable the bike is between test sessions. This is the KEY metric for our purposes during this phase of the study; validating that each bike within itself is reliable. From a practical standpoint, we need the difference between tests to be low if our handicaps are going to be valid and useful from one class to the next. In looking at both Bike 15 and Bike 9 we see that these are indeed fairly low — an initial good sign — and there is only one instance where the difference is over 10%. That’s actually a lot less than I expected.

Column: DELTA Original vs Retake
This is a “pre-handicap” column — showing the exact wattage differences at each stage of power averages. While this will produce precise numbers with decimals, we know that a practical application of handicaps would likely need to be in increments of 5 so that the math is easier when performing that handicapping in ones head. We could also use this to send to an automated system if one was ever created that could account for bike variations in the software (an insightful feature I would create if I were the purveyor of such software).

we use this column to evaluate the exact differences and averages before we designate a specific handicap number.

This column is the one that also really shows the amount of variation from one bike to the next. On Bike 15 we are averaging in the teens with wattage differences, whereas Bike 9 is averaging in the 20s and 30s. That’s quite a spread.

Column: Potential Handicap
This column would represent the entire motivation and impetus for all of the time and energy being spent on this research. We want to handicap the bikes! If you’ve read my eBook on Power (if not, no worries an updated iBook is due out soon — shameless plug apologies ☺ ), you will know that Power is not linear in its progression. As such we can not just use one number as the handicap and apply that to all wattage levels. If you look at all 4 bikes, you will see, with the exception of Bike 15, the differences get bigger and bigger as the wattage level increases. This is the exponential nature of power and the reason why I propose a handicap value for every 25 or 50 watts.

How About Some Analysis
Up to now, we’ve only sprinkled the analysis or possible conclusions as I’ve described each column. However, in order to even think about drawing conclusions, we will need more data points than just 2. Lets’ show four more bikes so we can see if there are some patterns emerging when we have 6 total bikes and their retests — giving us a total of 12 tests or sets of data points to consider.Bike-5Bike-17
Looking at Bike 5 I’m feeling pretty good that it’s similar to #9, this time with all variation under 10% and the good power-like escalation of Potential Handicap wattage going up as a power curve would reflect. Taking a look at Bike #17 though, and I had to do a double take — WHAT?? or should I say “WAATTT!” The degree of variation is crazy. Not only that, even looking at it from a practical perspective, the Potential Handicap, aside from being huge in the 30 to 60 watt range, is simply not close to either of the trials in this study. While 30 Watts may indeed be the average between the two tests, with one being 13 and the other being 44, who knows if 30 will be too much or too little. In fact all of the stages are reflected as pretty wild for Bike 17.

Bike-16      Bike-3

Unfortunately the bad news continues with Bike 16 and Bike 3.  Both of these bikes have variations well above 10% and similar wide swings in Watts for the original delta between tests.  In addition, we have bike #3 not demonstrating the proper power curve through the last 4 stages, but instead settling into one consistent difference in wattage.

Looking again specifically at these last 3 bikes, and there is no way I would be comfortable handicapping these bikes and expect it to be consistent.  So all in all, we have 3 bikes that look like they would lend themselves to reliable handicaps, and three that do not.  With a split decision like that, we are all but a hung jury here.

Since I recognized that I might be the problem — I am the only one conducting the tests – and while it stands to reason I would get better and more consistent over time not less, I did not want to rule that out.  This data left me scratching my head more than anything else — more questions that need to be anwered.  It was time to bring in bigger guns than I have.

The next blog will have another video where we brought in a professional statistician to help us get to the bottom of this.

Indoor Cycling Power Research #4: Chasing Reliability

Indoor Cycling Power Research #4: Chasing Reliability

Vector Pedals on Keiser M3

Making sure this process is repeatable with each bike tested is essential to our objectives.

Let’s recap what we’ve done so far in our video blog series:
1. We have introduced the whys and wherefores of this Indoor Cycling Power research project
2. We’ve shown exactly how the Garmin Vector pedals get mounted to the Keiser m3 indoor cycle bike
3. We’ve demonstrated from start to finish, the precise protocol used in conducting repeatable tests on each bike
4. Last week we stepped through the process for getting the data from both the Garmin bike computer and the Keiser m3 console (manually recorded) put into the a consolidated spread sheet.

Accuracy & Reliability Are Two Different Things
This week we move into the steps required to begin validating the reliability of our equipment and/or our process. This is as crucial a consideration as the pure accuracy of the data. If we can’t confirm that our process of measuring power is consistent on any one given bike from one day to the next, how can we expect to handicap the bike for accuracy with a number or even series of numbers for different wattage levels since an unrepeatable test would mean this handicap would not be valid from one day to the next.

http://vimeo.com/79224390

Indoor Cycling Power Accuracy & Validation Research from Cycling Fusion on Vimeo.

Consider the frustration of weighing yourself each day on a scale that can not show you 50 lbs from a 50lb weight from day to day. On some days you’ll be depressed while others you’ll be “woo hooing” all the while your weight has stayed the same. It’s an absolute critical component of our findings; to know what we are doing is repeatable and reliable.  If it isn’t, we need to consider if the process is changing and causing the inconsistencies, or if the equipment is doing so. While I have tried to be more than methodical about every aspect of this process from pedal calibration to bike test execution, I will not rule out tester error or inconsistency for the moment. Let’s just first see how our numbers turn out before we decide which factor to consider (test process, or equipment variability).

Gene Nacey & Keiser m3

Coach Gino Explains Why Validation & Reliability Are Important

The 2 video segments that make up this post are both quite short. The first one describes in detail how to unmounts the Vector Power pedals in order to use them on a second bike. It is important that we don’t just leave the pedals on and do multiple tests on the same bike. This would not tell us if that bike will be reliable one day to the next. We must first test other bikes, and then come back to bikes we’ve tested.

The second video segment is showing one complete test again (like our 2nd video), only this time on one of the bikes already tested from a previous session.

http://vimeo.com/79824570

Indoor Cycling Power Accuracy & Validation Research from Cycling Fusion on Vimeo.

ICI Podcast 278 – SpinPower Instructor Training First Report

ICI Podcast 278 – SpinPower Instructor Training First Report

Dennis Mellon

Now that StarTrac is shipping Spinner® Blade Ion Indoor Cycles with Power, there’s a bunch of Instructors who need to be educated on how to effectively use this new training “tool” in their classes.

Spinning’s new education program is called the SpinPowerâ„¢ program. It was developed by well known Power Training expert Angie Sturtevant who’s the Director of Power-Based Training.

When ICI/PRO member Dennis Mellon told me that his club in Greenwood Village Colorado would be hosting a SpinPower training, I asked if he would be willing to share his experiences with our listeners.

Dennis Mellon is one of those smart, talented people we love to have on the Podcast. Here’s his bio…

Dennis Mellon has been working in the Fitness Industry since 1992. He’s a Certified Personal Trainer/Performance Enhancement Specialist through the National Academy of Sports Medicine as well as being a certified Spinning, Energy Zone and Indo-Row Instructor. He has a Bachelors Degree in Physical Education and a Minor in Coaching from the State University of New York College at Cortland. He spends most of his time at Greenwood Athletic and Tennis Club in Greenwood Village Colorado where he is a Personal Trainer, Masters Swim Team Coach, Indoor Cycling and CardioVascular Intervals instructor. Dennis was voted the Mountain West’s top Spinning Instructor by Competitor Magazine in 2012. He has completed 8 Ironman distance triathlons, ultra distance mountain bike events, marathons and numerous shorter distance events.

Listen to the Podcast below or to subscribe to the free show in iTunes.

Please share this with your friends.

ICI/PRO is the leader in Power related class profiles and online education. You can sample hundreds of premium member articles, Podcasts and Audio Class Profiles as part of a trial subscription. Click here to get started.